On Bad Movies
Or, why "Plan 9 From Outer Space" is better than "Attack of the Killer Tomatoes."
I saw Ed Wood today, and it got me thinking.
Okay, Plan 9 was a bad movie, but it was trying to be bad. You can tell that they were trying, even if everything else about the movie was bad.
Attack of the Killer Tomatoes premise is meant to be humorous, it's trying to be funny.
Plan 9 is not trying to bed, so it becomes so-bad-it's-good. You have fun trying to make fun of it. Killer Tomatoes is meant to be taken seriously, meant to be so bad it's good. It's smart enough to know what it is, and then it becomes pretentious. The enjoyment from an ironic distance can't be enjoyed, because you know that's how it's meant to be viewed. Ironic distance is distance from how it's supposed to be viewed.
There's a scale of -1, 0, and +1.
For a movie like Schindler's List, that's a +1.
Normal movies are on a O scale.
Bad movies, like Plan 9, are -1.
Now, ideally, so-bad-it's-good enjoyment because the movie thinks it's a 0, but it's a -1.
With some movies, you go in thinking it's a 1, but it's a +1.
But Attack of the Killer Tomatoes is bad because it knows it's a 0, and it's a 0. There's no enjoyment.
That is my formula for so-bad-it's-good.
I saw Ed Wood today, and it got me thinking.
Okay, Plan 9 was a bad movie, but it was trying to be bad. You can tell that they were trying, even if everything else about the movie was bad.
Attack of the Killer Tomatoes premise is meant to be humorous, it's trying to be funny.
Plan 9 is not trying to bed, so it becomes so-bad-it's-good. You have fun trying to make fun of it. Killer Tomatoes is meant to be taken seriously, meant to be so bad it's good. It's smart enough to know what it is, and then it becomes pretentious. The enjoyment from an ironic distance can't be enjoyed, because you know that's how it's meant to be viewed. Ironic distance is distance from how it's supposed to be viewed.
There's a scale of -1, 0, and +1.
For a movie like Schindler's List, that's a +1.
Normal movies are on a O scale.
Bad movies, like Plan 9, are -1.
Now, ideally, so-bad-it's-good enjoyment because the movie thinks it's a 0, but it's a -1.
With some movies, you go in thinking it's a 1, but it's a +1.
But Attack of the Killer Tomatoes is bad because it knows it's a 0, and it's a 0. There's no enjoyment.
That is my formula for so-bad-it's-good.